Short Manga Tag

[Siranto1]

A tag for manga that have really short chapters (max 10 pages or so) would be a pretty useful tag imo.

 

[justforthelulz]

I think this idea has been suggested and rejected multiple times.

 

[Siranto1]

@justforthelulz Oh I didn't know. Why tho? Is it because some manga have really variable chapter lengths?

 

[justforthelulz]

@Siranto1
These two previous threads address the suggestion of tagging short chapters.

Having tags strictly for length is just an indicator thing, would be better fit by counting the number of pages in a chapter and having it displayed.
If we ever did that. But we likely won't anytime soon.

Short Chapters Tag: https://mangadex.org/thread/251768
"Micro Comic" or "One Page Comic" tag?: https://mangadex.org/thread/236585

 

[Siranto1]

@justforthelulz Thanks. It's a bit sad that it won't be implemented.

 

[schlo]

i'd rather see a promo tag. I've read a couple where they were promo's. Wouldn't have bother if I knew they were promo's some were 1 chapter, 1 was 3 chapters and another was longer.

 

[bigtiddyoneesan]

@bonobong

BAD BOT

 

[hazzack]

one same bot with two different links. how curious.

 

[konzolmester]

As much as I would like to say yes to this, it would only harm a lot of mangas. Take me for example, I see a manga I want to read and it turns out to be a weekly release 10 page manga. But I still got hooked on it because it has a lot of redeeming quality. Now if I were to filter it out with the said short manga filter than basicaly an oodles amount of readers would never get to experiance these kinds of mangas.

 

[REDRED]

I all depends on how you specify "short manga". What would be the qualifications?👾

 

[Syri]

It's a difficult thing to decide on really. You can get some with only 7 chapters, but each is 80 odd pages long, giving it a total length that's more than some with 50+ chapters. Then you've got additional complications like filler pages (a lot have a few pages of character designs etc) credit pages and such. All of that pretty much rules out any automated process, and then you're down to whether one person considers it short. This is of course without then debating where the line is drawn, is a 9 page per chapter considered short? Does that mean 10 is long? There's just too many variables really, and not enough reason to do it for it to be worth it, in my view.

 

[bastek66]

Something like "1 page chapters" would be useful