Release That Witch - Ch. 121 - Church's Disaster
- Thread starter MangaDex
- Start date
Contributor
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2018
- Messages
- 96
Another "new human type" plot shit, eh, and like always no logic.
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Nov 21, 2018
- Messages
- 420
well, that's really more just his first supposition. I'm thinking its more that the magic coursing through them is toxic to being able to conceive. I mean, if they don't use their magic power consistently enough growing up, it causes severe pain and possibly kills them.
I actually don't remember them ever mentioning periods with witches in the WN
Double-page supporter
- Joined
- Apr 2, 2019
- Messages
- 3,374
That does explain it. Genetic differences between races and species make it so that it's harder for hybrids to be born.
Now, I may not be a hardcore biologist, but witches that can't have children just means their ovaries are in need of additional power.
"Additional Pylons required."
Now, I may not be a hardcore biologist, but witches that can't have children just means their ovaries are in need of additional power.
"Additional Pylons required."
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2018
- Messages
- 2,345
@Moridin69
No i dont think they did.....
But they did mention everything else that was in this chapter.
It might be that magic is toxic somehow, in that chase it might be fixable in the future....
But if becoming a witch really changes you on a genetic level it might be hard to ever have witch babies even with modern tech that is really hard to do.
@HeroicPasserby
There is plenty of logic behind it actually....
Its pretty rare for two creatures of different species to have offsprings even in the best chases.
The question comes down to how becoming a witch changes people.
If they change genetically it's perfectly understandable but for the plot purpose the effect is what mathers just like Roland said.
That means if Roland marries a witch then that means he have to get a heir some other way like a concubine/extra wife or adopt.
No i dont think they did.....
But they did mention everything else that was in this chapter.
It might be that magic is toxic somehow, in that chase it might be fixable in the future....
But if becoming a witch really changes you on a genetic level it might be hard to ever have witch babies even with modern tech that is really hard to do.
@HeroicPasserby
There is plenty of logic behind it actually....
Its pretty rare for two creatures of different species to have offsprings even in the best chases.
The question comes down to how becoming a witch changes people.
If they change genetically it's perfectly understandable but for the plot purpose the effect is what mathers just like Roland said.
That means if Roland marries a witch then that means he have to get a heir some other way like a concubine/extra wife or adopt.
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jan 27, 2018
- Messages
- 1,008
There are no male witches, so they're not a new species. Just infertile individuals. Maybe mutants.
Contributor
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2018
- Messages
- 96
@Goldenzeal Witches are just women and are born from human parents. The problem is that the author wanted to create a harem for the MC, so he "sterilized" them and created nonsense about a "new human type". He didn't predict that his wife would decide what the plot should look like. Unfortunately, chinese authors have a problem with the fact that their better solutions are simply old one with a certain drawback: so witches are defective women who cannot have children.
In other words: the new type of man presented by the author is so great that it is a worse version of a normal man. And this so-called witch magic is strange, the powers of witches look like a children's fairy tale. Where's the sense, where's the logic?
In other words: the new type of man presented by the author is so great that it is a worse version of a normal man. And this so-called witch magic is strange, the powers of witches look like a children's fairy tale. Where's the sense, where's the logic?
Dex-chan lover
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2018
- Messages
- 2,345
@AlmondMagnum
There are species who dont have males at all and are only have females. ( Parthenogenesis )
Sure its abit of a strech to call them a new species and i agree that mutants might be a better word.
But just because there are no male witches dosent mean they can't be a new species is all i wanted to say.
@HeroicPasserby
You are making a lot of assumptions there friend.
I agree that the witches are a borderline harem even if only 2 of them actually wants his attention...
Not really sure i would call it a harem if its only 2 people but anyway that's splitting hairs....
And just because you don't like the given reason for them being sterile doesn't make it any less valid.
You could easily have had a harem without the witches being sterile.
Heck even if they were sterile and he had a harem it would have had little impact on the overall story.
As for witches being a better or worse type of humanity that purelly your opinion as you clearly are getting stuck up on the sterile thing.
In truth its mainly there to give the author a reason for the witches to NOT form romantic relationships with other people and make the few that do more.... unique.
I mean it's a fantasy story anyway so you will have to have some suspension of disbelief, just because you don't like the given reasons for it doesn't make it any less logical.
There are species who dont have males at all and are only have females. ( Parthenogenesis )
Sure its abit of a strech to call them a new species and i agree that mutants might be a better word.
But just because there are no male witches dosent mean they can't be a new species is all i wanted to say.
@HeroicPasserby
You are making a lot of assumptions there friend.
I agree that the witches are a borderline harem even if only 2 of them actually wants his attention...
Not really sure i would call it a harem if its only 2 people but anyway that's splitting hairs....
And just because you don't like the given reason for them being sterile doesn't make it any less valid.
You could easily have had a harem without the witches being sterile.
Heck even if they were sterile and he had a harem it would have had little impact on the overall story.
As for witches being a better or worse type of humanity that purelly your opinion as you clearly are getting stuck up on the sterile thing.
In truth its mainly there to give the author a reason for the witches to NOT form romantic relationships with other people and make the few that do more.... unique.
I mean it's a fantasy story anyway so you will have to have some suspension of disbelief, just because you don't like the given reasons for it doesn't make it any less logical.
Contributor
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2018
- Messages
- 96
@Goldenzeal I don't make any assumptions. These information are public and is not new. You can check it yourself by reading the comments under the novel. I also suggest you read other works from China. They have similar elements regarding the "new human type" or obtaining immortality. I treat them like anime tropes from Japan.
I referred to sterilization because it is the most simple to understand. Other elements are the witch powers themselves, which make no sense, these do not come from parents.
By the way, please don't put anything in my mouth that I haven't written. The plot is not logical, because a mare cannot give birth to Pegasus just as a woman cannot give birth to a new kind: "witch".
If you like this novel, it's good for you. I don't like reading comics, where the main elements are nice drawings and pseudo-scientific gibberish.
Happy reading and best regards
I referred to sterilization because it is the most simple to understand. Other elements are the witch powers themselves, which make no sense, these do not come from parents.
By the way, please don't put anything in my mouth that I haven't written. The plot is not logical, because a mare cannot give birth to Pegasus just as a woman cannot give birth to a new kind: "witch".
If you like this novel, it's good for you. I don't like reading comics, where the main elements are nice drawings and pseudo-scientific gibberish.
Happy reading and best regards
- Joined
- Mar 29, 2019
- Messages
- 1
Am I the only one is bother by the rethoric spewed in this chapter? " And as for me who has the spirit of a modern person, maintaining my bloodline isn't all that important to me". "Children are entirely separate entity since they cannot pass on ideas or inherit methods( therefore they are not important)." "Altogether this is good news ( its good thing you can have sex without wondering about having kids)". Like wtf is this bullshit? Apparently, the only thing that is important is abstract "concepts" and "knowledge". Curious if anyone here have some sort of family issues since I don't see anyone taking offense to this but me...
Fed-Kun's army
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2018
- Messages
- 268
@HeroicPasserby
You need to make a big old caveat for that statement you just made and that is "on Earth". But it's been explicitly stated that MC isn't on Earth but rather in some other unknown place where magic is real. Like, your point stands if we're talking about the X-Men from Marvel or something - people don't just random "mutate" in the form of suddenly waking up with superpowers, it's ridiculous and unrealistic. But when you add "magic" into the equation suddenly a lot of things that were impossible before become possible. You might think that it's a cop-out to just say "magic did it" but that is literally the in-universe explanation - the world Roland has transmigrated to is operating on different rules where mares can, in fact, birth Pegasi.
You need to make a big old caveat for that statement you just made and that is "on Earth". But it's been explicitly stated that MC isn't on Earth but rather in some other unknown place where magic is real. Like, your point stands if we're talking about the X-Men from Marvel or something - people don't just random "mutate" in the form of suddenly waking up with superpowers, it's ridiculous and unrealistic. But when you add "magic" into the equation suddenly a lot of things that were impossible before become possible. You might think that it's a cop-out to just say "magic did it" but that is literally the in-universe explanation - the world Roland has transmigrated to is operating on different rules where mares can, in fact, birth Pegasi.
Contributor
- Joined
- Mar 22, 2018
- Messages
- 96
@sinkingship
Well, I'm human, so I judge other people's work from the perspective of what people think is normal. In the way you give, you can explain everything, no matter how far away it will be from human experiences and principles.
I understand that there are people who consider such things to be normal, but decency requires you not to impose your views on others.
Unfortunately on MD many people want to force others to their views.
Well, I'm human, so I judge other people's work from the perspective of what people think is normal. In the way you give, you can explain everything, no matter how far away it will be from human experiences and principles.
I understand that there are people who consider such things to be normal, but decency requires you not to impose your views on others.
Unfortunately on MD many people want to force others to their views.
Contributor
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2018
- Messages
- 1,756
Dumb fool opened them the door...
Note: I really really really hope, the mc goes the polygamy route in this series...! (Would break my heart otherwise...)
Note: I really really really hope, the mc goes the polygamy route in this series...! (Would break my heart otherwise...)
Member
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2019
- Messages
- 304
Personally, while Anna is smart, she's not really a common reappearing character in the route. Nightingale shows up more often and is more active with the Mc, it doesn't make sense that Anna is the romantic interest. =w=
Afterall, she only shows up when she's useful.
Afterall, she only shows up when she's useful.
Yeh this modern person thing he says is non. Romance with Anna is also not that interesting, she gives the impression of being a a girl still, while nightingale often appears more womanly and they have more interactions and feels like Anna would be just fine with acquiring knowledge from Roland and being a major contributor to tech, while Veronica is around Roland so much its painful too see her being rejected.
Also far more likely that the mana in them is toxic, which would explain the infertility, either toxic to the ovaries making them infertile or toxic to sperm which would then require something of the same level that could handle the mana.
All these and other little annoyances add up which made me leave the WN in hiatus so far despite reading so many chapters...
Still this is adaptation does seem to have cut a lot of extra (filler) content, leaving the story a bit more focused. Kinda curious to see how goes forward here, but sad to see some pain points which lowers my expectations for "fixes". And its nice to see drawn, this format is better for this wn.
Also far more likely that the mana in them is toxic, which would explain the infertility, either toxic to the ovaries making them infertile or toxic to sperm which would then require something of the same level that could handle the mana.
All these and other little annoyances add up which made me leave the WN in hiatus so far despite reading so many chapters...
Still this is adaptation does seem to have cut a lot of extra (filler) content, leaving the story a bit more focused. Kinda curious to see how goes forward here, but sad to see some pain points which lowers my expectations for "fixes". And its nice to see drawn, this format is better for this wn.
- Joined
- May 21, 2018
- Messages
- 3
@CiaranBlood I also hate it when they shove that "modern nonsense" down your throat. Gives me "HaVe LeSs KiDs To SaVe ThE wOrLd" vibes. I also hate how they almost encourage you to not have kids these days... China-wise this could be the aftereffect of the 1-child policy.
