A Returner's Magic Should Be Special

You need to log in to comment.

Ch. 39
Avatar
I love this manhwa.
Please bring it back someone.
(´°ฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅω°ฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅฬฅ๏ฝ€)
Avatar
@maffo666

Gosh, that's a total clusterfuck and embarrassment. What senseless drama.
Avatar
@kayriel whilst I don't know the detail, it's something to do with trolls, being ungrateful and money or at least that's what I've managed to piece together.
The leader of the 'current' scanlation team has relations with a lot of teams (possibly led all of the ones on this manga, not sure) and made them all pull the manga.
For more information you may want to look at the comments on the whole series, not this 1 chapter, it goes back about 10 days.
https://mangadex.org/title/31551/a-returner-s-magic-should-be-special/comments/
Avatar
Why the hell was the reupload pulled, too? Mangadex is looking less and less ideal.
Avatar
raw still chapter 65
Avatar
Wait...what?
Avatar
guess so
Avatar
So uhh, I guess whoever translated every other chapter had them all pulled?
Avatar
@Shakur I guess that makes sense. If it was known that the chapters where coming out that day. Making the next one would be the better option.

@Swim_North Sitting back hoping you end up picking up some of the mangas some seems to have dropped for no reason (wish I had those in my list still)

Alot of desent manga translations have been dropped for no good reason and I still wanna read em XD
Avatar
Excsdee
Avatar
Lmao this is still ongoing?

Get over it people, Meraki scan doesn't even care since the sniping is of shit quality anyway lmao
Avatar
@Swim_North keuk
Avatar
edit: I have been told by someone I think is from Meraki that this Filipe guy is from another group and not Meraki. Well what I decided doesn't change but I want to make it clear that this weirdo guy commenting isn't actually in Meraki. Thanks for the correction.

After this really poor reaction from Meraki I have dropped my intention to do 41. It is a shame but did not expect them to do all these petty conspiracy theories and comments which make them look bad to their supporters including myself. So I don't want to deal with them. I was hoping you would skip the chapter I did or ask to use my work as a base with no compensation but crediting my reddit but instead you all do this. I was a solo translator. This conspiracy accusation and derailing threads is rude and makes you look poor. And of course I would make new accounts to post translations since it is a grey area to post but not to read and comment about. It took me maybe 4-5 hours which is not surprising I feel. You can believe it was some jealous scanlator group if you want, it only hurts your trust in the community to fantasize about enemies in your competition not me. Idk what to say other than thank you for chapter 40 which I will go read right now

@Filipe I don't really care anymore how you react but I will say this. If you believe this was someone else you know and blame or attack them for it you are pathetic and attacking someone not involved at all while also attacking a bored fan who tried scanlating for the first time. It's sad and it will only hurt your group, but you can do what you want I guess. And of course I merged the pages are you dumb. Who would want to keep track of so many tiny images and do them all individually.

@kah0922 Sorry but I was in a big rush to finish so Meraki would hopefully not have started any of 39 before I could post so there is no redundant work. But then they decided not to skip 39 so it didn't matter in the end

Last edited 5 mo ago by Swim_North.

Avatar
If you're gonna snipe, at least try to make your editing not trash.
Avatar
And it goes back to who gets to use what resource. It would be better for the reader, does not make it right to tell them they cannot or should not express themselves the way they want. Only the owner of the original art, through legal means, can control who has the RIGHT to reproduce the work. If it is open to everyone, than everyone has the right to produce their own interpretations however they see fit. You want to control it, pay for the domain and control who can post what in there.
Avatar
Oh okay @Filipe thats kinda petty of him
Avatar
@Xike
Not necessarily. Scanlators who are doing the considerable work for free, as a hobby and as training, are only humans. They need their motivation, which isn't coming from money like when people do usual work for living. Now, I have never worked in a scanlation group, but back in the day when anime fansubbing was still more prevalent, I did some work there. I'd say I was happy knowing people downloaded and watched the eps I worked on. To make this speech a bit more relevant, our group picked shows that weren't necessarily the most mainstream ones, and thus might have been left unsubbed otherwise. There are plenty of manga that has never been translated or ended up dropped and unfinished by one or more groups. So, it might be better for us, the readers, if free people capable of translating adopted one of those instead of a series already being translated.
Avatar
ya'll are literally making this a much bigger issue than it really is lmao
Avatar
This is art on a shared release platform. They have a right to express their artistic interpretation. If they have to hide behind a mask it is evidence of the harmful toxicity in the community.
Avatar
Why would that be an idiot thing to do? If it's something we enjoy and is interesting as well? You're reading manga too aren't you? Otherwise why would you be here?
Read older comments