Mushoku Tensei ~Isekai Ittara Honki Dasu~ Japanese

You need to log in to comment.

Vol. 9 Ch. 45 - Aisha's Allegience.
Avatar
makes me sad how Zanoba's introduction got thrown under the bus like this
Avatar
@gum_rummy
Dunno how it is in this particular isekai but normaly bastards dont even get to see their noble parents
If they want to keep her around and properly raise her without her suffering too much prejudice then they pretty much have to make her a maid
Avatar
@goodhunter....no one has said they want them to be perfect. Pointing out their flaws is part of the discussion.
Sometimes those flaws make them worthy of disdain too.

Paul reminds me a little of Stanley Kowalski from A Street Car Named Desire.
Avatar
People here need to understand that these are flawed people. Just like people you see today everywhere. They're not meant to be perfect or ideal, and that's what makes these characters great
Avatar
Aisha's precious but I really hate the idea of her being made a maid for her sibling just because of her parents' actions? That's not fair to her. Siblings should be equal.
Avatar
@adfjs I don't let Lillia off the hook either. It's pretty bad that Aisha thought her mother cared less about her than the rest of the Greyrat family until she risked her life to protect her when they got transported to the castle. I understand Lillia's devotion to Rudeus, but that is her burden to bear, not Aisha's. Neither Paul, nor Rudeus nor Zeneith ever expected Aisha to dedicate her life to Rudeus, and I think Zenith was almost happy enough to raise Aisha as if she were her own daughter.

However, none of that assuages my hatred for Paul.
Avatar
@HOOfan_1 Paul did rape her in the past and is scummy but Aisha's conception was due to Lilia blackmailing him into sticking it into her. It was heavily implied that she actually held his "weakness," IYKWIM to sleep with him.
Avatar
@jak Nah, regardless, the maid's the one who decided that Aisha would serve Rudeus since he saved their lives during the family meeting. All this hate towards Paul, yet no regards to the maid who have blackmailed him into sticking it into her?

Last edited 2 mo ago by adfjs.

Avatar
@Yautja
I haven't seen one convincing argument for something more than 3 months.

Only because you don't want to look at my picture I posted before, as your argument would crumble.
https://mangadex.org/thread/36705
Page 5, near the bottom.
Avatar
@Yautja I know what you meant. I think everyone should just be happy Seven Seas or Media Factory don't start sending out cease and desist letters. In other words just be happy you can keep doing what you love.

Last edited 2 mo ago by HOOfan_1.

Avatar
@Hoofan_1
Unless it wasn't clear, I was referring to fan translations. Obviously there are 'official' translations being done by companies that do have legal rights for translation. Those aren't really a subject for discussion when it comes to how long it takes for a series to be marked as dead, fan translations and the moralities and such surround "sniping" a series for a multitude of obvious reasons. I don't know if you were trying to be cheeky or pretentious but no one likes an obvious nitpicker, especially when it's clearly not related to the discussion. I think it's fairly obvious none of what was discussed by anyone below applies or was said in reference to legal translations.

Last edited 2 mo ago by Yautja.

Avatar
@Yautja actually someone does have the right to it, Seven Seas. They legally have a right to translate it to English.

@jak...not just bang the maid...but rape her

Last edited 2 mo ago by HOOfan_1.

Avatar
@Amplify I appreciate the tl;dr and link.
Avatar
@Amplify That would be if it actually stuck to a monthly schedule. LetItGo Scans seems to like to abandon series for months at a time only to then come back when someone else starts translating it again so they can claim that they were sniped.
Avatar
@colxeric
They are, at least to the majority of people and those with fully functioning brains. 3 months has been the standard for a decade or so. I haven't seen one convincing argument for something more than 3 months. If you have a 3 month, 6 month, or year long delay, the translation is dead and you don't get to go "but wait I still wanna do it" for your own ego, certainly not without criticism, as the translator for this series tries to do. Especially not when there's multiple groups of people out there willing to translate it and many people who want to read it. The arguments I have seen for this ridiculous position are the most unintellegent, emotional, illogcal and childish possible assertions. I haven't seen any consistent, reliable translation that go more than a month in between uploads. It shouldn't even have to be explained how ridiculous it is to badger other people about picking up a project that literally no one has the rights to.
Avatar
@colxeric
It's really not. Groups get delayed all the time for things like university finals, considering most of the people in scanlation are students doing it as a hobby in their free time. A year is a certain time frame, that way there can be no one bad period of time in that year that caused the delay as it's the entire year.

There's tens or more manga series out there than there are groups who can work on them, so the only way anything really gets done is with a gentleman's agreement between most groups to only work on any given series if it has nobody else doing it.

Last edited 2 mo ago by Amplify.

Avatar
Updates "within the last year" is a ridiculous time frame. If a group doesn't release for 3 months—that is 3 releases for a monthly manga—the series should be considered abandoned by the group. The series should be up for grabs after.
Avatar

I'd have just PMed this instead of airing it in public, but the coward has me blocked.

Last edited 2 mo ago by Amplify.

Avatar
Oh look, the narcissist and the delusional return again, still blowing each other, with another late reupload. At least this one is only a week late instead of a month, so there's an improvement there at least. Maybe the narcissist will reach a half way decent schedule that doesn't require other people uploading before him by the end of next year. It also looks like the delusional has reduced his absurd 1 year claim down to 6 months after being thoroughly disproven. Which is hilarious considering he ignored the validity of Baka-Updates. Maybe next chapter he'll get it down to the accurate 3 months.
Avatar
@GalladeGuy
Then you must be very new to manga translation. Monthly is not in the least bit slow, especially for a monthly LN manga adaptation series like this one - I could name dozens of similar manga with exactly the same release rate or slower. As for wishing somebody else would take the series, you'll find that 95% of groups won't work on a series that has any releases at all in the last six months at least (as recorded by Baka-Updates, rather than uploads here or similar, and then under a year only if it's been dropped) and only the greediest of cash grabbing groups or similar will snipe a series like that.

Just the way it is, no use being impatient about it and best to spend that spare time finding other good things to read too. I could recommend some stuff based on your tastes and if you want Manga and LNs or just manga and how important of a factor the release rate for it is, if you're up for that.

Last edited 2 mo ago by Amplify.

Avatar
Gotcha thanks for letting me know @GodricKharg and @Amplify. Looks like your translations are more accurate/contextual anyways.

And yeah too bad OT had to drop, Teras seemed like he was super busy last year with the new job (or was it school/test, forgot). Anyways that deja vu thing was a mindfuck haha but I read the entire WN/LN already so I ain't mad. Looking forward to your great work. Hopefully no more drama comes this way again
Avatar
@Amplify Let me rephrase that. I hope someone who uploads at a reasonable pace picks this up.
Avatar
saved by the weaboo dogeza!
Avatar
@GalladeGuy
But there's somebody already working on it, is there not? You're commenting on a chapter done by them.
Avatar
What a magnificent prostration!
Avatar
this is becoming more of a re:zero than mushoku tensei
all these chapter-looping shenanigans....
Avatar
Hopefully someone else will pick this up, now that the other group is gone...
Avatar
@TreiloStonefell
Next month we will probably get c46, then a month after that will be c47 and so on.
Avatar
reupload?
Avatar
@Amplify what does this mean for the rest of the chapters ? ? ?
Avatar
aisha is cute asf.
Avatar
Deja vu! I've just been in this place before!
Avatar
@Luhood they gonna smash?
Avatar
What is this, dark sorcery?!
Avatar
Mysteriously, I know exactly what will happen next in the story.
Avatar
Just seems like every group and reader site wants to monopolize everything. I get there's principles involved, but sometimes I just want to read the manga in a timely manner.
Avatar
Thx for the chapter. Much better translation
Avatar
@Amplify nice info thank you.
Avatar
@Kyujyu
Check out my post below yours for what's going on there.
Avatar
Was the previous chapters uploaded without permission or something?
I don't mind re-posting of the chapter by different group but why does the previous chapters need to be deleted?
Avatar
@LordDiablo @herrosenpai @skulz @S0lid_Sn4ke @Nes370
There's a whole drama about that, if you guys want a tl;dr on it as best I understand it then read on:
Basically the other group has something kind of fucky going on with them, they're being sponsored by another site to do certain translations and then redirect people to the reader that site is building, and it seems that site (I've not checked it out) breaks the 'excess profiteering' rules of MangaDex so they were offered a choice of either removing the link from their group profile or have their group be banned from MangaDex. They chose to be banned but the staff forgot to lock the group name from being remade, so some time later some guys (no idea who) remade the group under the same name and uploaded 3 or 4 Mushoku Tensei chapters here before the mods caught on and deleted the group again but this time locked it so it can't be remade.
Read more here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/mangadex/comments/a14zpb/stolen_translation_group_scans/
Avatar
Chapters were removed and this one was reuploaded? Not sure what's going on.
Avatar
i am feeling a dejavu here dont know why, werent this chapter and a couple of more released already? or it was another group?
Avatar
Things like this are the main reason why sometimes I feel like going crazy. Good to think it's world this time, not me.
Avatar
@herrosenpai

The Other Group drama, Im sure its covered elsewhere.

The problem is we had some issues with timing and staff after LetitGo began helping One Time with the project, and of course the hiccup with One Times' status which resulted in CAT joining the mix.

I'll say the same thing I've said elwhere... there are series (this one is one of them) that I promised Teras' at OTS that I'd see it gets our best treatment and continuation, and that I plan on keeping.

I have the next couple chapters and they are being worked on, various states of completion even.

@redice

LOL

@LordDiablo

And your point is...? see mine above.


@jak

Remember the alternate world and harems are okay issue... yes, sure, it would have been different if 'mom' would have known ahead and it wasn't just a 'i need sex and she's being mean to me' which DOES warrant the scathing hate of him...

Last edited 2 mo ago by GodricKharg.

Avatar
DEJA VU ! I've just been in this time before!
Avatar
@LordDiablo they were also out on mangadex ... dunno why they removed them ?
Avatar
Actually, I find this translation being more accurate to the raws than the other translation. Particularly the scene where Aisha is lamenting over being denied by her "onichan", before getting corrected. I do like the speed of the other translation group though. Well, each their respective qualities.
Avatar
@LordDiablo thx man!
Avatar
wait wtf...i read this already. looks like the other translations were removed
Avatar
I have nothing against chapters being uploaded multiple times by different groups, but this series really pushes it, lol. Every chapter starts with "Have I read this before couple of months ago?".
Avatar
ch.46,47 & 28 are already out in mangakakalot
Avatar
I feel bad for Aisha. Born into believing she needs to serve her brother all because their piece of shit father decided to cheat on his wife and bang the maid.
Avatar
aight

Last edited 2 mo ago by talisay999.

Read older comments